
Ohio State Lima 2010
Creative Nonfiction
Creative Nonfiction
First Place
Prose Arbuckle Award
Prose Arbuckle Award
2010 - 2011: Never Give an Old Person Green Bananas.
Lynsey Kamine
Lynsey Kamine
Driving
on rain danced roads down to the funeral home:
Squeeze
some lemon and add a pinch of salt. Drink it up, lap it up, but don’t
spill it on the pieces, on the fragments of disjointed teddy bears scattered on
the table. Start piecing together the edges, then work your way in. And
so I did. Want to whistle while we work? But I couldn’t; my
stubborn lips only blew hollow air, but yours blew with the grace of an
orchestra. Teddies finally resurrected under my pursed, trying lips. Next up:
marbles. A game of Chinese checkers will decide who gets to pick tomorrow’s
matinee.
*
Bananas, the fruit of
your Daily Bread. Mom brought you some towards the end and you
said: Never bring an old person green bananas. I laughed a chunky
laugh because it was funny. Mom didn’t get it. And you laughed,
even though your body begged you not to, as the cancer laughed in the face of
the banana’s potassium and dietary fiber. An inside joke.
*
With
a little tug, all of your teeth came out! They just popped right out like a
Jack-in-the-box! “Can you teach me how to do that?” You laughed and told
me your secrets. Pull up, shift down, yank a little, shake a little and
voila! Pop goes the weasel! And so I pulled and shifted and yanked and shook
while you laughed and smiled the toothless grin I so yearned to emulate.
*
Nobody
laughs at God in the hospital. I’ll see ya later. What am I
kidding? I won’t see you later.
Another joke. “Aw, Grandma, don’t talk like that.” A Marine’s son, an aerodynamic
engineer with a 12 o’clock shadow and a quiver in his lip leaned over you, and
you told him: Thanks for coming, now get back out there. Let the young
move on, we have yet so much to do.
*
My hair, newly blond and
your meadow, freshly painted and framed just for me – for the brunette me who
had once picked you poison sumac from the field behind your house. With
my prize in hand, I marched through the field, ran past the barn – Lady woof
woofed, but I didn’t even stop to pet her – then I slammed the screen door on
my heels, and climbed the stairs to find you in the kitchen. Oh my God, go wash
your hands! Oh, Lynsey, use lots of soap! And so I lathered and scrubbed
between tears, though I could see you smiling in the bathroom mirror.
*
Tangle
me up in your arms and let’s rock on this porch swing until the chains break
and we slam into the pavement. You’ll spoon pecan ice cream into your dentures,
and I’ll clang the silver between my incisors, but we’ll both shiver the same
goose pimples as we hang over the Astroturf, swinging to the rhythm of our own
pendulum.
Rain
danced roads turned to iced ballrooms, as Grandpa took me close.
He
was the first to hold me when I was born.
A Different Kind of Sister
Alicia Lugibihl
Alicia Lugibihl
“I can’t see what’s happening,” I said to the
brunette girl sitting next to me. We had both walked in late to our 4-H
meeting and now had the honor of sitting in the doorway at the back of the
room.
“Don’t worry. We probably didn’t miss
anything,” she replied. We both laughed at the reality that our 4-H club didn’t
do much at meetings. We introduced ourselves to each other and I learned that
she would be enrolling in my school that coming fall. We didn’t know it then,
but at age 10, we had both just met our best friend. As years would go by, our
friendship would turn into a sister-like bond.
Brittany was speechless, and for her that was
amazing. It was the summer of 1999 and I had just told her that I was going to
have an operation to remove a cancerous tumor from my left leg. I needed her
with me. She was my best friend and I could not do this without her support.
She told me that she would be there for me, and she was.
Through all of the doctor’s visits and surgery,
she was by my side. Then her friendship was called to duty again. The cancer
was back and this time it required an entire knee replacement. I was horrified
and wanted to run away and never come back. Brittany was there with tissues in
hand as the reality of another week at the hospital in Columbus hit us like a
ton of bricks. She said she would go home and again pack her bag of things to
do in the waiting room. She used that same bag three more times, as the cancer
kept making its way back into our young lives. Year after year we grew closer together.
We had our fights and arguments, but they were nothing major. We did a lot
together. She got me to come out of my shell and do crazy things like playing
Frisbee at Meijer with pillows. She showed me that my leg couldn’t keep me
from experiencing life.
“Britt, I have to talk to you.” She knew I
had recently had a check-up in Columbus earlier that morning and from my tone,
that it hadn’t gone well. They had found the cancer for the fifth time.
“But you just had an operation three months
ago! How can it be back?” She was just as worried as I was.
My parents, Brittany, and I made our way to
Columbus to hear the “options.” The cancer was coming on strong and needed to
be taken care of once and for all. It was sitting on a major nerve.
Thankfully the tumor was low grade again, but if it returned, it had the
potential of being high grade which could be fatal.
We arrived at the doctor’s office, heard what
the doctor had to say, and Brittany and I were led to a separate room.
Emotionally weary, Brittany gathered her courage as she realized what was going
to happen to me, her “sister.” She plopped her faithful, worn bag onto the
floor and gave me a big hug. All I could see was her brown hair and noticed
she was sobbing with me. Brittany pulled back, her green eyes so abundant
with tears that she had to reach for the tissues and used several. It was as
if she was the one that would be having the amputation.
We made the best of the first week of our
senior year. Then we were off to Columbus. Brittany had become my protector. She treated
me normally but with respect. She would tell other people why I was upset or
crying or angry. She knew my every emotion and was beginning to learn what
triggered my emotions.
The surgery came and Brittany stayed with me
in my hospital room, as usual. We ordered food. Nurses brought us our own
laptop, a second TV/VCR, and a CD player. We had everything. Then it was time
to return to reality. Brittany came over to my house almost every day to see me
and brought me my homework. She believed I could do anything. She took me out
in her red Cavalier to go over to her house or we would go get fast food. She
knew that I would recover better and faster if I got out of the house.
I went back to school two months later, after
the begging from Brittany and my other friends finally gave me the courage.
The year went by quickly. Before long, it was time for graduation.
Brittany looked radiant with her glowing green
eyes and dark brown hair. Her white cap and gown made her look beautiful. We
could not believe it was finally here. The day we had been waiting for had
arrived.
“You gonna make it Hop-along?” Brittany asked
and gave me a wink, smiling. It was time to walk down the aisle to receive our
diplomas.
“Shut up, Two-legs,” I replied with a
grin. Only Brittany could make jokes about my leg. She and I would both get
offended when anyone else would try to crack a joke. Brittany, on the other
hand, had seen it all and knew exactly what I had gone through.
Now we are at college together. We are as
close as ever. There is something that we understand about the other. We have been through
things that most people will never go through. Most of these people do not
have someone like Brittany to help them. I am very lucky to know her. She is
unique in everything she does, for me and others.
Running for the Car
Jacquelyn Steineman
Jacquelyn Steineman
When I
was nine years old I slept about twelve hours a day most days so I could dream.
Anything could happen in my dreams. In them I could see Mom and the boys in
other places without our Dad. We had left home a few times and they were in
those places but, as if we had not come back. Even the battered woman’s
shelter, tall and white was preferred. As simple as every house was on the
street, the cars parked out front on the street, but with dry grass and no
flowers, it was friendlier than our house. The biggest problem at that house
had been keeping to a schedule to share with the other families. But my dreams
were where I wanted to be. When Dad would come home after work, we would all
suddenly need a nap, coming downstairs only for dinner while he was there.
After dinner my excuse would be that I needed to go upstairs to finish
homework. During the summer some other excuse would be used, whatever came to
mind to escape being in the same room as him. My brothers and I would go to bed
around eight so that we could be asleep no later than nine. This routine helped
us to deal with the real life that was ours.
As much
as I loved my brothers, I also felt a type of resentment at times. They were
the chosen boys. The boys were in the larger room next to mine; they had just
turned two and four. They had the bedroom at the top of the stairs. The only
problem with it was that I would have to walk though it to get to my room. They
had bunk beds and were allowed a mess. Their beds were also new, at least to
us. They made tents from their sheets to hang down from the top bunk to hide in
the bottom bunk. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles were the sheets of choice,
something else that they had that I didn’t: new sheets. They would fight over who
could pretend to be which one. Andrew would point but Michael would assign. The
two would try to sleep together on the bottom but were not allowed. Dad had
spent money on the beds and expected them to be used. He had covered them in a
large sheet of plastic when they were purchased to preserve them. Every
movement would make a crackling sound.
My
only privilege of being the older child was a private room. My bed didn’t
have the plastic. My bed was the one that the previous owners had left in the
house when my parents had bought it. The bed was probably close to thirty years
old by this point. I never was given anything new. Even undergarments would
have to be bought by someone else, Grandma usually, my Mom’s mom, so that I
could have at least them new. My clothes were from aunts that were close to
twenty years older than me. I would be wearing green blazers with large gilded
buttons and mustard colored parachute pants by twelve. I felt like this was my
punishment at times.
My
wanting this house was the cause of the family problems. It was now mine, and
my parents’ problems had seemed to get out of control once we were living in
it. I now know that it was Dad’s new job at Honda. He wanted a more
materialistic life and with Mom’s inability to handle any more than she already
was, this was not a good combination. There was my brother being born, his
adopting me being finalized. There was now a family in which he was responsible
for. The house brought out new bills, with new desires. The list of reasons and
excuses could go on for quite a while. The bottom line was that even though I
felt that it was all my fault for wanting us to have more it was not me, it was
Mom and Dad who were at fault.
I had
loved our house for years before we could call it ours. We had lived just down
the street before moving here. I was often told how I would walk down the
street and stare at it. I had memorized the address and when asked would give
it as to where I lived. The houses were back on the islands. Most were white
and plain. This house that I loved was a dark brown that now I refer to as like
poo, and close to the main street that connected the islands. It seemed so
large, a straight flat front, it had only three windows and a garage to make it
stand out. Coming from a little one story with no lake access, this massive two
story house on the water was amazing. Indian Lake, Ohio was a place where no
one wanted to live, except on the weekend during the summer. There were not
many full time residents but I had loved it. I loved not only living on the
lake but that no one was around when my parents started fighting.
I had
headed to bed at the normal eight-ish and had fallen asleep soon after but, I
was soon awakened. My Mom had screamed. Their fights were usually over quickly,
but not so this time, the yelling continued.
“What have you done now?” Dad yelled.
It was
her fault when he screamed. It always was according to him. He did nothing
wrong. She must have screwed up the checkbook or maybe not picked up something.
It could be the bacon for his weekend meal that he would treat us kids to. It
could have been that he was down to his last Diet Pepsi and she didn’t have
more for him waiting. It could have been anything. This time it sounded
like a money fight, which would be the worst.
“How
can a grown woman not even know how to add and subtract?” he screamed.
The words told me that
this could be a long night. I sat up in my bed. The old golden colored wood
groaned under the sudden movements, the springs squeaking uncontrollably. I
didn’t want to lose the comfort of my blankets. I knew though that if I was
awake, then so were the boys. I took my bottom blanket, a warm old off-white
fuzzy thing and wrapped it around myself as I got up. The inherited, faded blue
comforter was left behind.
“I’m sorry,” I heard Mom whisper. It drifted up through the squares of the
vent. It spoke more loudly to me than Dad’s yelling would.
As I
opened the door from my room to theirs, I looked down through the open vent. It
was a black square with chipping paint that we would usually huddle around,
twisting the slates one direction or another. We would watch and see what was
happening but this wasn’t a time to risk being seen by Dad. I could not see
Michael in his top bunk so I knew that he had already moved down. The shadows
moved behind the sheets that made our refuge. The turtles were lying sideways
so that the whole width of the bed was covered. It was no protection from the
words that drifted up so easily between the squares of the vent, but the lack
of light drifting up was comforting. With no light and just these hate words,
we three sat with our backs against the wall. I was in the middle and one boy
on each side. We could hear Mom fall into the stools in the kitchen. The metal of
the legs made a deceiving clinking sound that was almost musical.
“You
are just so God damn stupid. What is so hard about doing what I tell you?” Dad
yelled.
The
boys didn’t even ask what was happening anymore. It was an old story that was
learned too young. We sat and I tried to tell some nothing stories that I could
remember. Our books were downstairs so the stories were often made up ones. I
could remember most of If You Give a Mouse a Cookie. It was a cookie, milk,
straw, napkin, mirror, hair, his hair made a mess he will need to clean, then
need a nap and on and on. Something that could make someone act so submissively
was just wrong to me. It was a mouse controlling the boy, not even another
person. Here this boy is just doing what this mouse wants and then at the end
has this mess to clean up; he is exhausted and a mouse that just wants to start
the cycle again. The mouse was very annoying to me but Michael liked him.
Michael liked the idea of having someone listen to even a mouse.
I even
had made up a dinosaur story about a long neck looking for a home, for love. We
had seen The Land Before Time and loved the story as well as the music. There
was this group of kid dinosaurs of different kinds, working together to find
their families. We wanted to find a better one. I would eventually write it
down but having a copy of something that was so tied to bad time was not
something that I liked. I would stop telling stories for years after that. I
had hoped that my stories could help us; they did nothing.
“Damn you! How could you do this to me?”
Thud,
something had hit the door downstairs in the bedroom, the door had not been
closed completely. Mom hitting against it was not a good sign. It proved that
she was moving back and forth in the house trying to get away. The sound was
followed by someone gliding down to the floor. We knew that it had to be Mom.
We stopped talking and listened.
Smash,
clang: The sound of other things falling and being broken were not usual. It
sounded like glass breaking, keys jingling and papers rustling. Mom was back
between the dining area and the kitchen. The two were separated by a small bar
that came out from the wall. It was surrounded by the bar stools that we had
heard earlier - more leftovers from the previous owners. The bar was the catch
all area of the house. Mail would be left here, papers from school. Things that
Dad was suppose to see or that he thought would be important.
The
dining area was almost directly under the vent. We had not a kitchen table but
a bar, so it sat up higher than a traditional table. For Mom to have knocked
the stuff off of the bar she had to have had her arm out, maybe to try to stop
herself from falling. The image of my mom falling backwards with her arms out
was disturbing but the mail and everything that was piled on the bar falling
around her was more so. It was also another reason for Dad to complain, the
mess.
“You
are so worthless. Look at this mess. What were you thinking?” She could do
nothing right, not clean cook or take care of the kids, of him, the house, the
checkbook. The list would go on and on. The words finally started to take on a
distorted sound. They were so common to my ears that I would at one point stop
hearing the words and just the tone was left.
I was
not hearing anything but trying to block all out and just hold my brothers when
I heard another thump against the other door. The kitchen was separated from
the entry area by a door, and another door would lead you to outside the house.
It was a full body hitting the door and it was a new kind of sound. It
was followed by screams and a growl and more unfamiliar sounds that had me
pausing and speculating.
“God
damn it what are you doing?” Dad’s voice cursing spoke volumes. I stopped
speculating when I heard him followed by the door slamming closed.
Dad was
more than the normal mad. He was a not usually a curser and the door being
opened at all was remarkable. He having to close it though was not good. I knew
that this had started heading from bad to the worst that it could. I had to
leave the boys and venture down the stairs. I was the oldest and I was Mom’s
daughter, her ally.
“I’ve
got to go down there,” I almost whispered it. I tried to sound stronger as I
said, “You boys have got to stay here. I don’t want you two to move, just
wait.” There was no time for thought but action.
Michael
didn’t want me to leave. “It’s not safe for you to go alone.”
“I’ll
be careful. You just stay here and wait for me to come back. I need to know
that you guys are safe.”
“But
it’s not safe for you to go alone. I’ll go with you.” Michael was six years
younger than me but he was a boy and he thought that it was his job to protect
the girls no matter his age. This was in my opinion; thanks to T.V. and those
turtles, they could encourage the boys to act peculiar.
“I’ll
be fine. But I got to go now. You need to wait here.” I was starting to panic.
Mom needed someone on her side.
I
pulled back the sheets and exposed the refuge to the lights of reality that
came up as I climbed out. I ran down the stairs wishing that they would stay
back behind the sheet, wishing that the sheet had fallen back, that they could
just stay with each other. I heard the outside screen door’s metal bend and I
thought no more of the boys, but of Mom.
Mom had
been with Dad for years. He may have saved me from my first dad when he adopted
me so the bastard couldn’t see me anymore, but at this price I sometimes
wondered if it was worth it. The fights had been getting worse for so many
years that even she with all her innocence knew this but would still not admit
it. By the time I had reached the bottom of the stairs, I was panicked. Mom’s
car door had slammed shut. I opened the door to the downstairs unsure of what I
would find. It was not as bad as I had feared. The desk for Michael to do his
homework for when he started school had been flipped onto its side; he didn’t
start school for another year, I was not allowed to use it, I was too big. The
desk didn’t bother me at all. The bar stools had been pushed back into the wall
and the red and yellow faded tops of them blended into a dirty orange as I ran
past them. Dad’s voice had hit a dangerous octave of curses. The mail was
in fact all over the floor, some had even made it into the entry room. There
was broken glass; pieces were from the counter to the entry stairs. I almost
tripped over the stair down into the entry room trying to avoid everything,
going from one room to another.
Dad was
banging his fist against the driver side of the car while using his other to
hold onto it. Mom’s screeches were now the ones at a dangerous level. The
screeches were not of her being dangerous but that she was in danger. I reached
the screen door and could no more than look. The door itself was bent from my
waist at the handle, up to the top by the hinge. The metal had cracked the
paint off giving a distinguishable look, and the screen had come out.
The
little gray car was trying to move forward. It was if it had made it to the
stop sign and didn’t want to move any father. The chugging of starting and
stopping was confusing. It had made the left turn and was maybe a house
lengths distance from the stop sign. Mom was a blur trying to move back and
drive while also reaching out trying to claw at him. The discord of her actions
did nothing for her. He had managed to grab a chunk of her hair and had started
to pull.
Then I
heard something that will be remembered clearly for years. A neighbor came to
their door; she had on her white floor length nightgown and her hair up in a bun,
and she yelled out, “Cut out all that noise.” I could tell that she saw Mom and
Dad. She was looking right at them, two houses away from them. For hours after
I would wonder when the cops were to show up. But the neighbor never called
them. The cops never came. I should have known. She was always so rude to me
when I would try to sell her things that the school had given us. It didn’t
matter if it was candles, cookies, candy bars or anything else she wasn’t
buying from us. Her granddaughter was always selling the same thing and she was
going to buy from her. I doubted for years that she even had a daughter let
alone a granddaughter.
Mom was
screaming as she was being pulled through the car window. Dad looked back at me
and it was then that I realized that I to was screaming. I don’t remember
walking out to the edge of the driveway. His arm had these long slender red
marks from mom’s clawing but she had been pulled out enough that I could see
streams of blood from her head, her arm. Her hair normally a dry but neat
blonde had a look of having been caught in a blender, mixed in tangles of
blood. The scene was shocking. As Dad looked at me, he continued to hold onto
Mom, pulling on her hair as she still struggled.
“Go! Right now,” he yelled at me to go back inside.
I was
worried of what he might do, but I still didn’t want to leave. Mom just looked
as if she had been caught in the headlights like some poor animal at the mercy
of a larger predator. The total sense of helplessness was overwhelming. He had
pulled Mom out of the car and was dragging her across the yard. I knew that I
should listen to him but to leave Mom didn’t feel right still. She was still
crying and the total helplessness of everything was overwhelming.
“I’ll
come back, just let go.” She was barely whispering. I thought that Mom must
have felt my confusion. She had stopped struggling.
He
turned from her direction to mine. She grimaced as he jerked her hair
again. She repeated that she would come back inside.
“Don’t
do anything stupid,” he replied.
I
noticed that even as he let her stand to walk on her own from the driveway that
he did not really let go of her hair. I turned and ran for the door before he
had a chance to do more than open his mouth. I bumped right into the boys. They
had not listened. Actually, Michael had not listened and had dragged Andrew
with him.
I was
upset for them to have come down and seen. Then I realized that Mom had not
stopped struggling for me but for the boys. Dad had not stopped because I had
interfered but because of the boys. These boys had brought so much change into
the family. With them I got my dream home, but also came the nightmares. These
boys had everything now that I used to have. They were given new things from
toys to clothes. They were given the attention first when something happened;
they were so young it wasn’t as if they really cared about what Mom got at the
store or if Dad had done something fanatical. I pushed at them and we started
our trek back into the home that was filled with contradictions.
It took
us as long as we could make it last. I wanted to hear what was happening.
We had three doors to go through before we would be on the stairs that
would take us upstairs and leave Mom downstairs. Mom’s moans of pain were
barely audible over Dad’s rants. We went through the first door: the screen
door that led from the outside to the entry.
“This
is all your own fault. You are just worthless. You should just die. Why don’t’
you kill yourself and get it over with?” his voice was no longer shouting, but
it was deathly calm. He would continue for what would feel like forever. We
could fall asleep listening to him. He hated it when she made him do this. If
she would just pay attention and do as he said. If she didn’t run from him, he
didn’t like chasing her. She was not being fair to him, making him act this
way. Did she think that he liked doing this? The things that came out of his
mouth were so stupid, even to me. If we did something it was our fault no one
else’s but with him it was always her fault. He didn’t act this way because he
wanted to, she made him do it. They were still outside; we were just going
through the second door: the entry room to the kitchen, the heart of a home I
hear.
They
had made it into the house. He saw that we were not upstairs yet and he yelled
at us to hurry it up. “Now, go!”
Once on
the stairs I hurried up them to get to the vent. Dad shut the door behind us.
“If I see any of you kids looking down here and not in your own beds, I’ll be
up there when I am done.”
I was
not ready to test my own luck anymore. The boys had not moved from where they
were stopped at the top of the stairs. They did not move past me from where I
had fallen to my hands and knees to look down through the squares. I stood up
and closed the vent. I grabbed a hand from each and we walked to the refuge.
The idea of sleep was ludicrous but my body felt so drained from all the drama
that had consumed my day, my night.
After
each boy had climbed in the bottom bed they made room for me in the middle. It
was my assigned spot in their life. I crawled in and put my back against the
wall. One on each side and we didn’t speak. I just held their heads and hands
and made nonsense humming. No more words were wanted. It was time for the day
to end but there were still the words that would drift up. Mom’s cries were
still being torn from her body. Tomorrow she would be calm and tell us how she
had made it worse, that it wasn’t that bad but she hadn’t handled it right. She
had let it go too far. She would say anything that she thought would make it
better, would make it sound like she could help it from happening again. This
time there were no words that she could put together that would make that ever
seem possible. It would still be years before she would leave for good.
My
dreams from this moment on changed. Gone were the simple hopes that my Mom and
us could go and start a new life. They were no more, now they were of Dad
dying. There was no other way to escape him. Sometime he would die after the
police would finally come and he would resist arrest and they would have to
“take him down.” The gun shot would allow him to speak, so his last words
were words of regret. Or maybe sometime he could go out in his precious boat
and there would be a gas leak that would cause an explosion. Burning alive, he
would not be able to get away to the water, seeing but not able to help
himself: the helplessness. Finally, there were the dreams in which Dad would go
too far and Mom would finally kill him, with a knife usually. Stabbing him in
the gut and he would die slowly gurgling words that could not form, a look of
shock upon his face. These dreams scared me because I didn’t know what would
happen to Mom, or to us. If a neighbor would speak up and say “yes, he did abuse
her.” Or, if she would go to jail and then I would be alone with the boys. I
knew that she would be blamed even if she never would have. I felt that if
these were to happen that I would have caused them. That was scary in itself. I
missed the simple dreams of starting a new life simply away from Dad.

